Customize Consent Preferences

We use cookies to help you navigate efficiently and perform certain functions. You will find detailed information about all cookies under each consent category below.

The cookies that are categorized as "Necessary" are stored on your browser as they are essential for enabling the basic functionalities of the site. ... 

Always Active

Necessary cookies are required to enable the basic features of this site, such as providing secure log-in or adjusting your consent preferences. These cookies do not store any personally identifiable data.

No cookies to display.

Functional cookies help perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collecting feedback, and other third-party features.

No cookies to display.

Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics such as the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.

No cookies to display.

Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.

No cookies to display.

Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with customized advertisements based on the pages you visited previously and to analyze the effectiveness of the ad campaigns.

No cookies to display.

Opinion

NY’s Amish, vaccinations and the battle for the ‘greater good’

New York’s Amish community has become an unlikely minority on the frontlines of a battle pitting Constitutional rights against potentially draconian public health laws.

On March 3, the New York’s Second Circuit Court of Appeals ruled against Amish people who challenged a 2019 repeal of New York state’s longstanding religious exemption for school vaccination requirements.

That repeal, signed by then-Gov. Andrew Cuomo, followed four other activist states, including California, to impose state medical dictums on religious minorities.

New York’s Amish community has become an unlikely minority on the frontlines for religious exemption for vaccinations. ASSOCIATED PRESS

In New York, ending religious exemptions was triggered after a 2018 measles outbreak in vaccine-hesitant ultra-Orthodox Jewish communities. 

Measles — with a 0.1% mortality rate and once considered a natural part of childhood, like chickenpox — had been declared eradicated in the US until that flare-up.

A few years later, the assault by New York Democrats on religious minorities continued into COVID when New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio put locks around playgrounds in Hasidic areas of Brooklyn, even as restrictions were easing in other parts of the city.

The Amish sought exceptions from vaccine mandates for students within their own school system. AP

He also dispersed a Hasidic funeral using public shaming tactics and targeted synagogues for raids and closures due to social distancing rules.

In the most recent case, Amish schools were slapped with tens of thousands in penalties in 2021 for teaching unvaccinated students — despite their isolated campuses receiving no public funding.

The Second Circuit — stacked almost entirely with Obama and Biden appointees — is no friend to religious minorities, rejecting religious freedom arguments against school vaccine mandates in similar cases in 2015 and 2021. 

But the government’s botched COVID-19 response has ignited fierce debate over vaccines and bodily autonomy, now amplified with Robert F. Kennedy Jr. leading Health and Human Services.

There’s significant variation in attitudes toward vaccinations across Amish communities — but they share a historical skepticism in external authorities and their faith emphasizes self-sufficiency and a trust in God’s will.

They also have a pragmatic streak: While some ultra-conservative Amish communities outright reject all vaccinations, others may engage in a temporary acceptance when faced with an immediate threat, as happened during a 1979 polio outbreak in Amish communities across the Northeast and Midwest.

Former Mayor Bill de Blasio was at the forefront of vaccine and mask mandates during COVID. Stefan Jeremiah for New York Pos

Still, See you in court! isn’t something you’re likely to hear from the Amish; they tend toward the Christian teaching of turn-the-other-cheek. When a religious freedom case involving the Amish appeared before the Supreme Court in 1972, it was taken up by a Lutheran minister who provided legal counsel on their behalf. The Amish won when SCOTUS ruled Wisconsin’s mandatory schooling law violated the First Amendment’s Free Exercise Clause by forcing their kids past eighth grade against their faith. 

Yet public health precedent shifts the ground — SCOTUS has recently dodged tackling school vaccine mandates head-on.

Last year, the highest court declined to hear We The Patriots v. Connecticut Office of Early Childhood Development, the 2021 case coming from the Second Circuit that challenged Connecticut’s repeal of religious exemptions for schoolkids.

Health and Human Services is led by Robert F. Kennedy Jr. Getty Images

But pressure is building on SCOTUS to address the issue. “Our clients will be seeking review from the Supreme Court,” Aaron Siri, an attorney for the Amish, told The Post. “New York state brought this fight to the Amish by seeking to force this peaceful community to violate their sincerely held religious beliefs in order to attend their own Amish schools.” 

Last year, Alabama Attorney General Steve Marshall spearheaded a 20-state amicus brief supporting the Amish community’s religious freedoms in rural New York.

Sadly, precedent is not on their side. It means reexamining a landmark decision dating all the way to 1905, Jacobson v. Massachusetts, which affirmed a smallpox vaccination mandate and established states’ wide-reaching “police power” to safeguard public health, even at the expense of personal freedoms. 

Like the Amish, New York’s Orthodox Jewish communities have mandatory vaccine and masking orders. Getty Images

A later 1944 Supreme Court ruling reaffirmed this and read like a COVID-era CNN monologue: “The right to practice religion freely does not include liberty to expose the community or the child to communicable disease,” Justice Wiley Blount Rutledge, an FDR appointee, wrote in the 5-4 Prince v. Massachusetts decision.

But the First Amendment isn’t a suggestion.

The Amish might be the canary in the coal mine for even greater acts of over-reach committed by authorities when the next catastrophe hits — all in the name of the “greater good.” 

Last year, Alabama Attorney General Steve Marshall spearheaded a 20-state amicus brief supporting the Amish community’s religious freedoms in rural New York. Getty Images

Science and medicine have been warped by power-hungry Democrats to serve as cudgels against minorities they don’t like — both the Amish and ultra-Orthodox Jews heavily swing Republican. 

While vaccinations certainly can be part of maintaining that greater good, the Supreme Court must act when edicts cloaked in public health prioritize control over conscience. 

Source link

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button