Tone deaf: NYC DSA choir mocked for protest song longing for future with ‘no NYPD’

The New York City Democratic Socialists of America Choir is being mocked for a toe-curling tune longing for the day “when there’s no NYPD.”
Footage of the happy-clappy performance by the supposedly revolutionary choir singing new lyrics to the tune of “When the Saints Come Marching In” went viral online as critics marveled at how the group would be so proud of it.
The seemingly all-white choirists were filmed singing the song with the lyrics, “When there’s no NYPD, oh when there’s no NYPD, how I want to be in that number, when there’s no NYPD.”
“This is a cheat code to get the movement singing,” the group enthusiastically claimed on the initial Instagram post.
“It’s easily adaptable and people know the tune, making it great for marches and picket lines” and for when “the revolution comes,” the choir wrote.
They also offered other possible “zipper lines,” including “when the people own their homes,” “when healthcare is free of charge” and “when Palestine is free.”
The video, originally posted in September, went viral this week, even landing a feature on Fox News’ “Gutfeld” Thursday night, with critics dragging the singers’ message.
“Imagine all the stories we will have when all these people start getting robbed and attacked…Who are they going to call? Ghost busters?” one X user jeered in response to the clip.
“If you don’t want the NYPD and are disrespectful to the men and women who put their lives on the line for their community then you don’t have the right to call 911 in case of an emergency,” one netizen wrote in the original Instagram post’s comments.

“These are the people who call 311 multiple times a night because their neighbor is walking too loudly,” another quipped.
Others snarkily addressed how the revolutionary choir appeared to be made up of mostly white middle-aged women.
“This is crazy! If they are all there, who’s at home feeding all their cats??” one snark wrote.



